After the opening weekend of the English Premier League season, Liverpool find themselves third from bottom in the league table, courtesy of a 3-0 loss against West Brom at the Hawthorns.
Perhaps equally memorable for Zoltan Gera’s long-range strike as it will be for Liverpool’s double-penalty farce, the game marked Liverpool’s worst-ever start to a Premier League season.
The saving grace is that Brendan Rodgers has time to turn it around, but in an increasingly cutthroat Premier League, the Reds must rebound quickly.
Hindsight is 20-20, but let’s now consider five things that Rodgers got wildly wrong in an embarrassing result for his new club.
1. Failing to Set Up His Defence Against Shane Long
The first error was made painfully obvious even from the opening whistle.
Shane Long has been known for his industrious work rate leading the West Brom line, and the partnership of Martin Skrtel and Daniel Agger just didn’t do enough to contain his threat up front.
Taking their time on the ball and not being mindful of Long’s presence, Skrtel and Agger were at fault for the goal that secured West Brom’s eventual victory and for Agger’s sending off.
Whether the red card and the two penalties would not have been given in an alternate universe remains up for debate, but if Skrtel and Agger had so much trouble against a harrying Shane Long, how can they be expected to contain the likes of Carlos Tevez, Edin Dzeko and Mario Balotelli for Manchester City this coming Sunday?
2. Throwing Lucas Back into the Deep End
Last Saturday marked Lucas’ return to the starting lineup in a Premier League game for the best part of nine months.
Which in itself is commendable on Lucas’ part—but in hindsight perhaps Rodgers could have done more to ease him back into the team.
That Rodgers had no qualms about slotting him straight back into his starting XI was perhaps a testament to his faith in Lucas and Lucas’ own ability. While his partnership in central midfield with Joe Allen had plenty of encouraging signs, they were ultimately overrun by a physical duo of Youssuf Mulumbu and Claudio Yacob.
The argument for Lucas’ extensive gametime is perhaps that he has featured all throughout Liverpool’s preseason, but the EPL is a whole different beast.
3. Playing and Sticking with Stewart Downing
Stewart Downing was rewarded for his fine preseason displays with a starting berth on the right wing in a front three; only for Downing to reward Rodgers’ faith with a typically anonymous performance with no end product.
If there is one thing that Rodgers should take away from his opening-day loss, it should be that Downing only delivers in games against lower-league opposition (see his dazzling cup performances last term) and those with little to no implication (see his preseason displays and that in Belarus against FC Gomel, with whom a second leg at Anfield beckoned).
Time and again the ball fell at Downing’s feet, only for him to waste crossing chance after crossing chance, or to halt the play completely while he switched back onto his favored left foot (also known as his only operable foot).
Perhaps his replacement after Agger’s sending off—Jamie Carragher—could’ve done a better job.
4. Switching Luis Suarez and Fabio Borini’s Positions
After an eye-catching display against FC Gomel, Fabio Borini emerged as a decent goalscoring option for Liverpool, and his dovetailing with Luis Suarez seemed to be an encouraging prospect.
The Suarez-Borini partnership was going swimmingly until Rodgers decided to tinker with it by switching their positions.
Previously granted the freedom of the left wing, Suarez was utilized in a central striking role against West Brom, which allowed the opposing defenders to focus their attentions on him.
While his trickery and unpredictability still ensured that they had to endure an uncomfortable night, he failed to display the finishing composure that should be expected from a central striker.
By contrast, Borini, who previously excelled at finding the space that a predatory striker thrives on, was shunted out to the wing, where he, with lesser dribbling and outright pace, failed to trouble the West Brom defence.
Together with Downing, Borini formed an anonymous wing partnership and a toothless alliance with Suarez.
5. Delaying Andy Carroll’s Introduction
The nature of a Plan B is that it should be used if Plan A doesn’t work out.
But in the case of Andy Carroll, he might not even have taken to the Hawthorns pitch if it weren’t for Joe Cole’s hamstring injury just minutes after Liverpool’s No. 10 came on as a substitute himself.
In delaying Andy Carroll’s introduction, Rodgers seemed to tread in Kenny Dalglish’s footsteps, and that hesitancy and reluctance in making key substitutions will not augur well for both the Liverpool fans and for Carroll himself.
There is perhaps a case against sending on a striker—and a big targetman at that—when you are 3-0 down, but had he been introduced early, he would have given the West Brom defence something else to worry about against a 10-man Liverpool—and an extra outlet for the Reds attack.
The Silver Lining…?
The silver lining in Saturday’s cloud, of course, is that it was Brendan Rodgers’ first league game in charge of Liverpool.
The Rodgers revolution was always going to take time, and if anything, the West Brom result perhaps served to bring expectations down to earth, albeit in an extremely sobering manner.
Perhaps it will have taken such a result for Rodgers to realize some of the points made above.
Hindsight is 20-20, but retrospect is only useful when you act on your mistakes to tackle problems in the future.
The 3-0 loss against Steve Clarke’s side will have been for nothing if Rodgers doesn’t make changes accordingly in the games to come.
3 thoughts on “West Brom 08/18/2012: What Went Wrong?”
Rodger plays a high defense line, Carragher is definitely out of depth + skrtel lacks the speed, in addition, the final third did not have any penetration, midfield was dominated by the opponent….Also disappointing was the substitution, the 3 subs that came on was uninspiring and the lack of Plan B from his tiki taka is just very worrying…. Its really a disaster outing~~ However benefit of the doubt should still be given to Rodger given that the referee kills the match with a stupid 2nd penalty and we had a man send off…. next wk match against Man city provides the best platform for the reds to respond!!!!
Agree with you here – let’s see how Liverpool respond against City this weekend. We’ve traditionally been good against big team, so let’s hope Rodgers hasn’t taken that away! Ha.
Signed fowler and the other old guys bauecse i wanted to have them tutor my young strikers. but cant get them to tutor though ):Like or Dislike: 0 0